chu_hi_wines (chu_hi_wines) wrote,
chu_hi_wines
chu_hi_wines

Black Swan Merlot (2003)

I came across this Australian Merlot via the recommendation of the man from whom I buy my wine in New York. At $9.99 a bottle, the price was right (and these are Manhattan prices) and apparently it was popular that week.

This wine claimed to have "herbal" flavors. I found it a little bitter, which could translate to "herbal" with some imagination. The aftertaste is crisp and fresh. The bouquet is a bit cherry-like, to match the color (a smokey sort of ruby hue).

On the U.C. Davis 20 point scale, I'll give it a 14, with the lowest marks for "overall impression."

I'm going to try using the U.C. Davis 20-point method until I find something better, even though it isn't quite what I've been looking for. I've considered (up until now) using a comparison scale, comparing different vintages to songs (too subjective), classic cars (something I know nothing about), or postage stamps (perfect for me, but too much work to scan in stamps every time). So I'll try out Señor Davis until something better comes along. Suggestions welcome.

More debate over wine scoring can be found at the following links:
Santa Maria Times Wine Column
Wine Pocket List
Wine Anorak
Wines & Vines
Tags: australia, educational, merlot
Subscribe

  • Cellier d'Or Rouge

    A contender for "Most Boring Wine Possibly Ever." When I opened it, I wasn't too impressed with the nose; rather, I couldn't detect an aroma at all,…

  • Calvet Merlot 2003

    Color: Cinnaberry - the color of my hair now. Aroma: Winter berries with vanilla ice cream. Impressions: This breezy red is young and playful, at…

  • Wines on a Boat

    Here are a few wines I tasted at a tasting event on the cruise I took with my parents in November. The Riesling Chateau St. Michelle and the…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments